News for faculty and staff

Contact | Past Issues

Week of March 11, 2013

Henry Russel Lecture


House to address paradox of U.S. health care and health

Out of control spending on health care and insurance is a major cause of the current fiscal crises in the United States. Although the country spends far more on health than any other nation, it now ranks below all comparably developed nations — and even some developing ones — on major indicators of population health, such as infant mortality and life expectancy.

This, says 2013 Henry Russel Lecturer James S. House, is “America’s paradoxical crisis of health care and health” — spending more and more on health, but getting less and less in terms of positive health outcomes. In his Henry Russel lecture Thursday, House will address two concerns: why Obamacare and other proposals to reform health care will do little to reduce health spending or improve health, and how what has been learned about the impact of social disparities on health can actually improve health and lower spending.

House

The Russel lectureship is one of the university’s highest honors for its senior faculty, and House’s selection is no surprise, given his profound impact on the nation’s public health discourse. House is the Angus Campbell Distinguished University Professor of Survey Research, Public Policy and Sociology; research professor in the Survey Research Center of the Institute for Social Research; professor of sociology, LSA; professor of public policy, Gerald R. Ford School of Public Policy; and research scientist in epidemiology, School of Public Health. He has been elected to membership in the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, the Institute of Medicine, and the National Academy of Sciences.

House received his Ph.D. in social psychology from U-M in 1972, and he returned in 1978 as an associate research scientist and associate professor of sociology. During the 1970s and 1980s, he conducted groundbreaking studies showing that social and psychological factors, most notably social relationships and supports, could have as profound an impact on health as established health risk factors such as smoking and obesity. And over the last quarter century, House and others have shown that social disparities by race/ethnicity, gender, and socioeconomic position have even more profound effects on health.

But establishing that these disparities shape the experience of and exposure to virtually all major biomedical, psychosocial and environmental risk factors for health has been an uphill battle. The clinical medical community has gradually come around, House says, in part because clinicians daily see patients whose illnesses might have been prevented through earlier non-medical interventions, such as better education, income, and conditions of life and work.

But it’s been harder to reach other parts of the scientific community and those with the ability to change the system. “People who have the most influential positions in the policy making process in Washington and elsewhere are about as skeptical of the importance of social determinants and disparities as real causes of health differences in the population as the biomedical establishment was 50 years ago,” House says.

In 2008, House and several colleagues published “Making Americans Healthier: Social and Economic Policy as Health Policy.” The book tackles six critical areas that policy makers often overlook in public health calculations: civil rights, education, income support, employment, welfare, and neighborhood and housing. In an upcoming book, House will more explicitly show that these and other putatively “non-health” policies should be as central to health policy as health care and insurance are now.

These are also issues he’ll take up in his Henry Russel Lecture. No one can deny, House says, that the United States is doing something very wrong. “We’re now at the very bottom of all of the developed countries in terms of almost any indicator you can look at on population health, despite spending increasingly more on health than any other nation, and now more than we can sustainably afford.”

The trick for public policy is to change the social determinants and disparities at the base of these bad health outcomes, he says. Only this can substantially and reliably reduce the need and demand for health care, and the increasingly unsustainable spending on it as individuals, organizations, and a total society.

READER COMMENTS (1) POST A COMMENT 
Posted by Halsey House | Mar 17, 2013
It is about time that members of our government focus on the kind of causes that House has been studying for many years. It is a shame that political and profit considerations have dominated things in this area. I am disgusted that adds showing granny being thrown off the cliff are run by the American media. But, I guess money and power come first with many of our leaders. The bible says that there is a time to be born and a time to die. We need to ban together to make the trip through life as fulfilling as possible for all Americans, not just those with power and/or money. Unfortunately, the system has made things complicated and expensive. The recent lead article by Time magazine on our medical systems points out many of the problems with the system. It would be nice to have the best technology and medicines and be able to implement them in a helpful, reasonable way. That would be a win win for all of us. It is a shame that we have the first part, but not the second. Money and power should not be a consideration in having an effective system that serves our citizens. I hope a well thought out system that considers the causes of the current problems can be developed.


Leave a comment

All fields are required.




email address will not be shown


Please enter the words you see below for anti-spam purposes:
NO SPAM

 

FACULTY SPOTLIGHT

Dr. David Aronoff, an associate professor and medical doctor in internal medicine-infectious diseases, on what he can't live without: "My family. That’s the most important thing for me."

EVENTS

Violinist Anne-Sophie Mutter, 7:30 p.m. March 14, Hill Auditorium, sponsored by the University Musical Society.

View/Submit Events